Publication

Staking in the Proof-of-Stake System – Technical Principles and Tax Treatment

Nelli Hindsburg

Proof of Stake

 

Decentralized cryptocurrency networks require a consensus mechanism so that all participants can agree on the same transaction history within the network without a central authority. Proof of Stake represents an alternative to the Proof-of-Work method for establishing consensus within the network.

As in all blockchain-based systems, individual transactions are collected and grouped into blocks in Proof of Stake. These blocks are confirmed by participants in the network and continuously appended to the blockchain, thereby creating an immutable chain of blocks containing confirmed transactions.

In order to participate in this process, participants in the Proof-of-Stake method must deposit capital in the form of native protocol tokens and properly operate network-specific software. As a reward for participating in consensus, the network distributes tokens of the same currency, in an amount corresponding to a percentage, to the relevant actors (so-called validators).

The amount of the rewards depends on the respective network and its utilization (for example, in the case of Solana, in the range of several percent per annum). In the Ethereum network, approximately 38,980,554 ETH are currently staked and around 913,740 validators are operated. The current effective annual percentage rate (APR) for staking is approximately 2.9%.[1]

 

How Validators Work

Since 15 September 2022, the Ethereum network has been based on the Proof-of-Stake consensus mechanism. With the technical transition (“The Merge”), the previous mining process, which is inherent in the Proof-of-Work method, was completely terminated.

In Ethereum’s Proof-of-Stake method, validators deposit 32 ETH as a stake in a smart contract in order to participate in the consensus mechanism. Anyone who owns the blockchain’s native cryptocurrency (Ether) can become a validator. After the deposit, the Ether (ETH) is locked as collateral and the validator enters an activation queue.

Once a new validator is activated, the software runs permanently and keeps the validator synchronized with the Ethereum network 24/7. The computer on which the software is operated becomes a node (a so-called validator node) in the Ethereum network.

In every slot, approximately every 12 seconds, the algorithm checks whether the validator has an active role. Essentially, there are three different roles: the validator is the block proposer, the validator is part of the attestation committee, or the validator has no task in that slot.

In the role of block proposer, the validator collects transactions, creates a new block and sends it to the network. This block must refer to a previous block (generally the last block of the longest chain to date), so that over time most blocks unite into a single, continuously growing blockchain. This validator task is assigned every few weeks, depending on network utilization.

As a member of the attestation committee, the validator reviews the proposed block, validates the transactions it contains and casts its vote.

If the validator has no active role, it merely observes the network.

 

Validator Selection Process

In a Proof-of-Stake system, it is not fixed in advance which validator from the currently active validator group may create the next block. This is determined by a random-based selection process.

For example, if the validator group consists of Alice with 40 Ether, Bob with 30 Ether, Charlie with 20 Ether and David with 10 Ether, the probability that Alice will create the next block is 40%, Bob’s probability is 30%, and so on. In practice, not only a single validator is randomly selected, but a continuous sequence of validators, so that if Alice does not appear, another validator can step in after some time.

The randomness is therefore determined by the asset staked. In simplified terms, this can be understood like a lottery: a participant who stakes more coins receives more “tickets” and therefore has a correspondingly higher probability of being selected.

 

Slashing

Validators receive rewards for their activity (so-called staking rewards) in the form of Ether. These arise both from creating blocks and from submitting attestations. The rewards are credited automatically to the validator account.

Continuous availability is required. If a validator is assigned as a proposer or as part of a committee and is not reachable, for example due to technical failures, this may lead to sanctions.

These range from reduced rewards and temporary or permanent exclusion from the validation process to so-called slashing. In this process, parts of the deposited stake or, in extreme cases, the entire stake (32 ETH) may be lost. The risk is inherent in the system. In practice, however, it occurs only rarely. As a rule, it requires serious misconduct or significant technical misconfigurations.

The deposited capital therefore serves as a security mechanism and safeguards the integrity of the network. The economic commitment and potential sanctions create an incentive for compliance with the protocol rules and contribute to the stabilization of the system.

In connection with slashing, the question arises as to the use of the withheld amounts. In the Ethereum network, the affected ETH units are permanently removed from the system (“burn”). This reduces the total supply. A small portion may be paid as an incentive to validators who detect and report corresponding misconduct.

 

Staking – Tax Classification

According to the administrative view (BMF letter dated 6 March 2025, para. 46), the decisive factor for tax classification is the technical role assumed by the taxpayer within the network.

A distinction must be made between active staking and passive staking. In active staking, the user operates a validator themselves and participates directly in the consensus mechanism of a Proof-of-Stake network. The user is technically integrated into the network infrastructure. This is associated with their own technical responsibilities, ongoing operational requirements and specific risks.

For tax purposes, according to the view of the tax administration, such validator operation is generally classified as a commercial activity. This is justified by the close connection between the user’s own performance (validation) and the consideration granted for it (staking rewards), as well as by the active technical participation in the consensus mechanism.

In the literature [2], it is sometimes argued that validation contains elements similar to chance and is therefore not necessarily commercial in nature; however, this view does not correspond to the current administrative position.

In passive staking, the technical implementation is carried out entirely by a corresponding provider. The provider assumes responsibility for operating the required technical infrastructure. The most common use case is so-called staking pools, in which the tokens of several participants are pooled together.

For tax purposes, this is generally not considered a commercial activity, as no independent technical or organizational service is provided. According to the current view of the tax administration, the staking rewards generated are generally classified as other income within the meaning of Section 22 No. 3 EStG.[3] A tax-exemption threshold of EUR 256 per person and calendar year applies.

The classification is based on the so-called fruit-bearing theory: the capital employed is used to generate income, comparable to interest income. A commercial activity is only exceptionally conceivable, for example where there is a bank-like or service-provider-like activity on behalf of third parties.

[1] https://ethereum.org/staking/, as of 27 April 2026.

[2] Farruggia-Weber, Dietsch, DStR 2022, 8 et seq.

[3] BMF letter dated 6 March 2025, para. 48.